Is it worth it

Updated

Harold Halibut is worth the Steam list price if you want to wander a handmade ship and listen to it. It is a poor buy if you want combat, puzzles as the main activity, or a choice of endings. That split is the whole review story. On 17 November 2026 the US price was $34.99. The publisher's length is about 12 hours, up to 18 if you stay for everything. You are paying for time spent looking, not for a system to master.

Critics did not land in one place. Wikipedia's collected scores include IGN at 8 out of 10, GameSpot at 7, Shacknews at 9, Siliconera at 10, Edge at 5, and PC Gamer at 60 percent. Steam's own page quotes a precious, beautiful note from Kotaku AU, a 10 from Try Hard Guides, and an 8 from IGN for the handcrafted tone. Metacritic, via Wikipedia, sits at 69 on PC, 70 on PlayStation 5, and 74 on Xbox Series, in the mixed-or-average band. PCGamingWiki shows a single Metacritic figure of 73, which does not match those splits. OpenCritic is 58 percent recommend on Wikipedia and a 73 on PCGamingWiki. Sources disagree on those aggregate figures. Use the spread, not one badge. Players on Steam were kinder than the median critic: 81 percent of 1,238 reviews positive, Very Positive, with a Mixed 64 percent of 17 reviews in the 30 days before 17 November 2026.

What the low scores are reacting to

The walking is long. The days are errands. Shacknews, as cited by Wikipedia, described a game without conventional puzzles, without branching paths, and without multiple endings. A Tetris-like cleaning moment and the arcade cabinets exist, and they are seasoning. They are not the meal. If a 5 from Edge sounds like your taste in story games, trust that more than the Steam percent. If you loved the look of the store trailer, the 10s are the people who stayed for that look. The beginner guide tells you the pace in the first hour. You will know by the end of chapter 1 whether the remaining ten hours are a gift.

What the price is not buying

No co-op, no live service, no season pass, no code list. The soundtrack is $9.99 extra. Switch 2's 33 percent launch discount was announced without a printed sale price. Platforms and before you buy hold those facts. Steam Deck is Verified, which matters if the couch is a handheld. How long to beat is the clock. Endings is the promise of one conclusion, kept.

Verdict: Worth $34.99 for the sets and the quiet story. Not worth it as a puzzle game or an action game. The achievement hunt is optional and fiddly, and it is a better second reason than a first one.

FAQ

Are the Steam reviews a better guide than Metacritic?

They measure different crowds. Very Positive from 1,238 players means people who bought a slow story mostly liked it. Mixed-or-average critic scores mean reviewers split on the pace. Read both, then watch ten minutes of the trailer on the home page.

Will I miss out if I skip the missables?

You will miss achievements and some conversations. You will not miss a second ending. Missables is for the hunt. A normal play that talks to people still sees the story.

Is the awards list a reason to buy?

The press kit lists a Deutscher Entwicklerpreis 2024 win for graphics, a German Computer Game Awards 2025 win for graphic design, a Golden Joystick 2024 nomination for visual design, and a BAFTA 2025 nomination for artistic achievement. Those are art awards. They match the reason to buy. They do not promise a different kind of gameplay. Chapters shows the shape of the 12 hours.